This blog has several sections and pages describing evidence for three potential shipwreck sites near Warrnambool. These are where inland shipwrecks were reported in the Warrnambool sand dunes (known as hummocks) in the nineteenth century. Scroll down for the information about each site or click on the links to skip to the separate pages about site coordinates and Q & A.
During the nineteenth century shipwrecks were reported in several quite different places in the Warrnambool hummocks. Therefore, they cannot all be "The Mahogany Ship"! Some books about The Mahogany Ship emphasise three areas where inland shipwrecks were most often reported.
Site 1- scroll down - includes referencing for my video Quest for the Mahogany Ship
Site 2 - scroll down
Site 3 - scroll down
Separate information pages about site coordinates and Q & A
Finding Rob Simpson’s potential buried shipwreck sites (separate page - click on link below):
https://rsaustr.blogspot.com/2024/02/finding-rob-simpsons-buried-shipwreck.html
Rob Simpson’s Sites 1, 2 and 3- Queries and Answers (separate page - click on link below):
https://rsaustr.blogspot.com/2025/10/the-mahogany-ship-rob-simpsons-sites-1.html
Sites 1, 2 and 3
Three sites between the Australian towns of Warrnambool and Port Fairy could be worthy of archaeological investigation.
This article links to a video about my Site 1 and explains my Sites 2 and 3 in detail.
"The Mahogany Ship" is probably a popular collective title for several shipwrecks stranded inland in the Warrnambool hummocks that were observed in the nineteenth century. Witnesses didn't report that they were constructed of mahogany, but several mentioned the colour of mahogany. The Mahogany Ship is therefore probably not merely one shipwreck, but several shipwrecks that were stranded inland, and they were unlikely to have been built of mahogany. However I am not suggesting that the term "The Mahogany Ship" should be abandoned.
The YouTube link for Quest for the Mahogany Ship is:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f_FOkhnL4Go&t=649s
The coordinates at the centre of the site are: 38°20’58”S, 142°21’38”E. To find the site on Google Earth, copy and paste the coordinates without a full stop at the end in the search bar. Please note: Use Google Earth – not Google Maps.
Site 1 - Summary of the evidence in Quest for the Mahogany Ship:
Aerial imagery using the
principles of aerial archaeology provides very compelling evidence. This coalesces with the following spoken
evidence from literary sources. These are nineteenth and twentieth century reports that are compatible with one another, and with the aerial imagery:
John Mason: “halfway between
Port Fairy and Warrnambool”.
Alexander Rollo: “could not be
seen from the water’s edge, being high up in the hummocks”.
Alexander Rollo: “between two
hummocks a quarter of a mile east of Gorman’s Lane and 4 chains north from the
sea”.
Alexander Rollo: “opposite Helen
Rock”.
James Rock: “halfway between Gorman’s
Lane and The Cutting”.
Mrs Dickie: “close to the end of
Gorman’s Lane”.
Mrs Smith: “a short walk from the
end of Gorman’s Lane”.
Pat Maddon: “east of the lane, up near The Cutting”.
Referencing for the evidence as spoken in Quest for the Mahogany Ship:
The time of the start of each section of the Quest for the Mahogany Ship video is given in minutes and seconds:
4:05. John Mason in 1876 spoken by Daryl Francis:
John Mason speaking:
“Riding along the beach from
Port Fairy to Warrnambool in the summer of 1846, my attention was attracted to
the hull of a vessel embedded high and dry in the hummocks, far above the reach
of any tide. The hull was full of drift sand. The timber of which she was built
had the appearance of cedar or mahogany. The wreck lies about midway between
Port Fairy and Warrnambool, and is probably by this time entirely covered with
drift sand.”
Reference:
Powling, J.W. (2023) The Mahogany Ship: A Survey of the
Evidence. Osburne Group, Warrnambool. (p. 11). ISBN 0-9592576-3-2
Primary source:
Letter from John Mason to a leading Melbourne newspaper, The
Argus, in 1876.
6:08. Alexander Rollo spoken by James Simpson (stage name
James Jackson):
Alexander Rollo speaking:
“In the years 1854 and 1855,
when residing at South Warrnambool, I and others were in the habit of walking
along the Port Fairy beach. I remember a wreck that was lying far above high
water mark. Her stern pointed towards Port Fairy and only her timbers were
standing about three or four feet above the sand, surrounded with vegetation.
From the position and appearance of the wreck, I am perfectly sure, she came
ashore before the district was inhabited by Europeans. She could not be seen
from the water's edge, being high up in the hummocks.”
Reference:
Powling, J.W. (2023) The Mahogany Ship: A Survey of the
Evidence. Osburne Group, Warrnambool. (p. 21). ISBN 0-9592576-3-2
Primary source:
Letter from Alexander Rollo to the Warrnambool newspaper, The
Warrnambool Standard, in 1890.
7:10. Alexander Rollo spoken by James Simpson (stage name
James Jackson):
Alexander Rollo speaking:
“The wreck was between two
hummocks a quarter of a mile east of Gorman’s Lane and 4 chains north from the
sea.”
Reference:
Powling, J.W. (2023) The Mahogany Ship: A Survey of the
Evidence. Osburne Group, Warrnambool. (p. 21). ISBN 0-9592576-3-2
Primary source:
Archibald’s Notes Relating to the Ancient Wreck at
Warrnambool, Mitchell Library, Sydney.
13:14. Alexander Rollo spoken by James Simpson (stage
name James Jackson):
Alexander Rollo speaking:
“She could not be seen from
the water’s edge, being high up in the hummocks.”
Reference:
Powling, J.W. (2023) The Mahogany Ship: A Survey of the
Evidence. Osburne Group, Warrnambool. (p. 21). ISBN 0-9592576-3-2
Primary source:
Letter from Alexander Rollo to the Warrnambool newspaper, The
Warrnambool Standard, in 1890.
13:42. Alexander Rollo spoken by James Simpson (stage
name James Jackson):
Alexander Rollo speaking:
“It was opposite Helen Rock.”
I have altered the wording slightly for simplicity, but not
the meaning.
Reference:
Powling, J.W. (2023) The Mahogany Ship: A Survey of the
Evidence. Osburne Group, Warrnambool. (p. 21). ISBN 0-9592576-3-2
Primary source:
Archibald’s Notes Relative to the Ancient Wreck at
Warrnambool, Mitchell Library, Sydney. A1701.
16.40. James Rock spoken by Andrew Simpson:
James Rock speaking:
“There was a channel cut
through the hummocks by Mr Rutledge to drain a large area of swamp considerably
east of Gorman’s Lane. The wreck lies about half way between Gorman’s Lane and
this channel; but, if anything, nearer the channel than Gorman’s Lane.”
I have altered the wording slightly for simplicity, but not
the meaning.
Reference:
Powling, J.W. (2023) The Mahogany Ship: A Survey of the
Evidence. Osburne Group, Warrnambool. (p. 43). ISBN 0-9592576-3-2
Primary source:
McDowell, James. Letters to George G McCrae, 20 December 1909
and 21 January 2010. Flagstaff Hill collection.
17.54. Mrs Dickie spoken by Peg McGinley:
Mrs Dickie speaking:
“The Mahogany Ship was very
close to the end of Gorman’s Lane, a little to the east. A large spar or mast
was visible, sticking up out of the sand.”
Reference:
Henry, Jim. Alternative Locations for the Wreck of the
Mahogany Ship. In The Mahogany Ship: Relic or Legend? The Mahogany Ship
Committee and Warrnambool Institute Press, (p.91). ISBN 0 949759 09 0
Primary source:
Jim Henry, Warrnambool historian interviewed Mrs Dickie,
aged 84, in 1980.
18:27. Mrs Smith spoken by Roslyn Cooke:
Mrs Smith speaking:
“It had not been seen for some
years, but at the picnic somebody saw the ship, and most of the people went
over to it. It was a short walk from the end of Gorman’s Lane. Mother told us
the timbers were very solid and smooth, and polished (she supposed) with the
drift sand. The ship was well in the sand hills. It was seen a year or two
later but only the top timbers, then it disappeared and has never been seen
since”.
Reference:
Henry, Jim. Alternative Locations for the Wreck of the
Mahogany Ship. In The Mahogany Ship: Relic or Legend? The Mahogany Ship
Committee and Warrnambool Institute Press, (p.91). ISBN 0 949759 09 0
Primary source:
Jim Henry, Warrnambool historian, received the information
in a letter from Mrs Smith, aged 84, in 1980.
19:48 Pat Madden spoken by James Simpson (stage name
James Jackson):
Pat Maddon Speaking:
“East of the lane, up near the
cutting. My father-in-law had a cow that calved over that way, and when he went
looking, the calf could not be found. The old cow had hidden it in the
tussocks. He started to drive the cow home, thinking that she would break back
to the calf, but she did not. He met up with another local resident, Doherty,
and asked him to look for the calf, which was soon found. The calf was tied to
the wreck until it could be brought to the farm.”
I altered the wording slightly for simplicity, but not
the meaning.
Reference:
Henry, Jim. Alternative Locations for the Wreck of the
Mahogany Ship. In The Mahogany Ship: Relic or Legend? The Mahogany Ship
Committee and Warrnambool Institute Press, (p.91). ISBN 0 949759 09 0
Primary source:
Anecdotal evidence.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tplpFsnR6RI
Site 2 is explained further down the page.
Drone video at Site 2 by Andrew
Simpson.
Discovery of Site 2
Reference:
Frizell, Helen.
(1985) Secrets of the Sands. In The Proceedings of the First Australian
Symposium on the Mahogany Ship. (p. 26). ISBN 0 9599121 9 3
Primary
source:
The
article originally appeared in the Sydney Morning Herald, September 13, 1980.
Reference:
Powling,
J.W. (2023) The Mahogany Ship: A Survey of the Evidence. Osburne Group,
Warrnambool. (p. 15). ISBN 0-9592576-3-2
Primary
source:
Letter from
John Mason to T. H. Osborne, secretary of the Western Steam Navigation Company
at Warrnambool in 1890. Note that the same letter does not say where the
shipwreck was, although there was an accompanying map, now lost. The letter gives
the opinion that it would have been a small ship – but is vague on that point.
The site is therefore "almost in a straight line with those objects, well in the hummocks".
![]() |
| Tower Hill from the site. The old iron church was just to the right of the peak. It is sometimes called "Tower Hill Island" because it is nearly surrounded by lakes - not because it is in the sea. |
![]() |
| The old iron church. |
Reference:
Powling,
J.W. (2023) The Mahogany Ship: A Survey of the Evidence. Osburne Group,
Warrnambool. (p. 28). ISBN 0-9592576-3-2
Primary source:
Letter of March 20, 1890 from James Lynar, Port Fairy Postmaster in the late nineteenth century to Joseph Archibald. Lynar and Mills were acquaintances."I cannot give you the exact time, but I think it must be 40 years ago, he erected a fence for the Warrnambool Borough Council across the hummocks, about three-quarters of a mile east of Gorman's Lane. When he came home after completing the contract he informed me that he came across an old wreck high up in the hummocks, and I believe he said it was to the eastward of the fence but I cannot say the exact distance. It was within a half mile of the fence and nearly buried in the sand."
Reference:
Powling,
J.W. (2023) The Mahogany Ship: A Survey of the Evidence. Osburne Group,
Warrnambool. (p. 29-31). ISBN 0-9592576-3-2
Primary
source:
Saul, W.
Letter to E. P. Cleverdon, April 28 1909. Flagstaff Hill collection.
Reference:
Powling, J.W. (2023) The Mahogany Ship: A Survey of the Evidence. Osburne Group, Warrnambool. (p. 78). ISBN 0-9592576-3-2
Primary source:
Sketch Map from Joseph Archibald's Paper to the royal Geographical Society of Australasia, June, 1891.
November 2 and 3, 2017 – Los Angeles movie studio scout and producer
November 12, 2017 – Los Angeles movie studio crew
The Los Angeles movie studio spent the day at the site filming. They were at Warrnambool during the week filming material connected with the Mahogany Ship. The documentary will be shown on American TV during 2018.
![]() |
| Some of the film crew assembling near the site. |
January 15 to 17, 2018 – investigation with auger
Two associates and I drilled with an auger in 7 places at the site. We drilled to depths of 2 to 4 metres. Unfortunately, we were not able to strike anything solid.
![]() |
| Jason Brewerton at the site with the ground-penetrating radar equipment. |
![]() |
Standing on the same arm, taken
from the south after the site became more overgrown with vegetation. |
![]() |
| The hummocks |
“On the hummocks almost directly opposite the end of the road, about 2-3 chains [40-60 metres] in from the sea, on the side of a dune stood two masts which I and others climbed on.”
However I have taken photos and videos, and it has been investigated with GPR.
Copy and paste 38°21'17" S, 142°23'16" E into the Google Earth search bar, then go to Search/View/Historical Imagery/adjust the slider to 2/2007/then zoom in. The shape and the wall are then very easy to see.
Reference:
Henry, Jim. Alternative Locations for the Wreck of the Mahogany Ship. In The Mahogany Ship: Relic or Legend? The Mahogany Ship Committee and Warrnambool Institute Press, (p.95). ISBN 0 949759 09 0
Primary source:
Letter and map from Mr R. Scutcheon of Ballarat.
Wall at Site 3
Immediately next to this shape and only 10 metres from it is an almost completely straight wall that is 200 feet long. It can be seen clearly on Google Earth and also at the site. Today it is covered in vegetation. I have been unable to measure the height, but it was taller than me and very easily recognisable. Might is be a sealer's wall? I suggest this as there is a sealer’s wall on King Island (238 kilometres south of Warrnambool) that resembles it. The Warrnambool wall is of course covered in sand, and it is therefore impossible to know what it is constructed of underneath the sand.
Articles and photos can be found online by typing in “Sealer's Wall on King Island”.
Reference:
Bateson, C. (1973) Dire Strait – A History of Bass Straight. A. H. & A. W Reed, Pty. Ltd. Sydney. (p. 70 and 71 – photo and caption of the King Island Sealer’s Wall). ISBN 0 589 07116 5








